Nov. 18, 2014

Did Nietzche Speak Buddhism?

From Ashoka Speaks by Maurice L. Harris (author's profile)

Transcription

Did Nietzche Spake Buddhism?

"Dead are all Gods; now we *WILL* that superman live....

I *teach* you superman. *MAN* is something that *shall*
be SURPASSED. What have you *DONE* to surpass him?...

What is great in MAN is that he is a *BRIDGE* & _not_ a
goal: what can be loved in MAN is that he is a *TRANSITION*
& a *DESTRUCTION*.

I love those who do not know how to live in except in
perishing, for they are those *GOING BEYOND*.

I love the great despisers because they are the
great adorers, they are the arrows of longing for the
*OTHER SHORE*.

I love those _WHO DO NOT *SEEK* BEYOND THE STARS_ for a
reason to perish & be sacrificed, but who *SACRIFICE*
themselves to *EARTH* in order that *EARTH* may some day
become superman's....

It is time for MAN to mark his goal. It is time for
man to plant the *germ* of his *HIGHEST HOPE*....

Tell me, my brethren, if the goal be lacking to humanity, *IS NOT HUMANITY ITSELF LACKING?*...

Love unto the most remote man *IS* higher than love
unto your neighbor."

- Friedrich Nietzche, "Thus Spake Zarathustra," (1883) (Durant, 1961, p.544)

Upon first reading this, I was immediately struck by the similarity between Nietzche's superman & a Buddha. Both are MAN (& WOMAN) in their most exalted state, a principle eloquently codified in the Buddhist concept of *the 10 worlds*. (See note 1)

"What is great in _man_ is that he is a *BRIDGE*... a *TRANSITION*
& a *DESTRUCTION*."

In the 10 worlds HUMAN is found in the middle, as a *BRIDGE*, in the state of *TRANSITION*, to the upper realms (of consciousness). As Nietzche states, MAN is not the goal, but, 'shall be suprassed.!' To do this, one must destroy (*DESTRUCTION*) his/her lower-self.

"I love the great despisers... longing for *the other shore*"

The *OTHER SHORE* (or, 'opposite shore') is a venerable metaphor in Buddhism, representing *NIRVANA/ENLIGHTENMENT*. Concisely, one has to cross from the shore of delusion/illusion (*worlds 1-6*), to the *OTHER SHORE* of enlightenment, by away of a SEA OF OBSTACLES/SUFFERINGS (i.e., life's challenges), & *SACRIFICE* (for Humanity; Think of Gandhi, M.L. King, Malcolm X, Abe Lincoln, et al. Btw, this doesn't have to be to the extreme of death, but, the sacrifice of a life of comfort; Think Mandela, or, even Pussy Riot & Snowden). This leads to Nietzche's great question: Without an aspiration for the *OTHER SHORE*, *'IS NOT HUMANITY ITSELF LACKING?'*

Then this excerpt ends, with a seemingly superficial statement:

"Love unto the most remote man is *HIGHER* than love unto your neighbor."

However, this is a very humanistic illumination. Isn't it easier to love someone that's in close proximity to oneself? But, to have this same type of love for a stranger, clear across the globe, is *DEFINITELY* a *HIGHER FORM* of love (*AGAPE*).

Once again, this begs the question, "WHAT HAVE YOU *DONE* TO SURPASS MAN/WOMAN? :)

Oct. 10, 2014

* EARTH: an esoteric symbol of TRUTH, WISDOM, & MORAL PERFECTION, also, *DHARMA*.

1. The 10 worlds are different states of consciousness a person may dwell in, depending on one's disposition. Each state contains the other 9, therefore, are not fixed, allowing for the *TRANSITION* (potential) to higher states. They are, in ascending order: *1. Hell:* State of misery & suffering. Self-destructive. *2. Hunger:* Endless desire; never satiated. *3: Animality:* Ruled by the 'Law of the Jungle'; Fear the strong, but prey on the weak. - These 3 are known as the __3 evil paths__ - *4. Anger/animosity:* Persistent, though not necessarily overt, aggressiveness. Dominated by _ego_: arrogance/pride/superiority complex. *5* Human beings* (also, world of HUMANITY): Self-control of desires & impulses with REASON & acting in harmony w/environment & other people, while *ASPIRING* for a *HIGHER STATE* of life [worlds 6-10]; *6. Heaven:* Contentment & joy when released from suffering, or the satiation of some desire. This is a *TEMPORARY JOY* that is dependent upon external factors. - _1-6 are called the *6 paths*_. - In the 6 paths one's happiness is vulnerable to changing circumstances. - *7. Learning:* One is dedicated to creating a better life through *self-reformation* & *self-development* by learning f/the ideas, knowledge, & experience of predecessors & contemporaries. *8. Realization:* Perceiving the impermanence of all things & strives to free oneself f/the sufferings of the 6 paths by finding some _lasting truth_ through one's *own observations & effort*; *9. Bodhisattvas:* Compassion. A state where one thinks of & works for others' happiness even before becoming happy oneself (*Altruism*). A bodhisattva seeks enlightenment while helping others to enlightenment; *10. Buddhahood:* State of perfect & absolute freedom, where one realizes 'the true aspect of all phenomena & the *true nature* of life.' One achieves this by manifesting the *Buddha Nature inherent in one's life.* Due to the presence of the other 9 worlds, one still has to fight & *defeat* the negative functions in life, & *TRANSFORM* any & *ALL DIFFICULTIES* into *CAUSES* for further development. A state of COMPLETE ACCESS to the _boundless wisdom_, _compassion_, _courage_ & other qualities *inherent in life*. One uses these qualities to create harmony with, & between *ALL LIFE & NATURE.*

SOURCES

Durant, Will. (1961). _The Story of Philosophy_. (New York, NY: Simon & Schuster, Inc.)
Soka Gakkai Dictionary of Buddhism, The. (2002). (Tokyo, Japan: Soka Gakkai)

Favorite

Replies Replies feed

We will print and mail your reply by Monday, 12 May 2025. Guidelines

Other posts by this author

Subscribe

Get notifications when new letters or replies are posted!

Posts by Maurice L. Harris: RSS email me
Comments on “Did Nietzche Speak Buddhism?”: RSS email me
Featured posts: RSS email me
All Between the Bars posts: RSS